Please Subscribe to Unlock

Before we even sat down in the Bat Cave for annual tasting of Thomas Bachelder’s Touissant (All Saints Day Nov 1) release, it was obvious that his focus is increasingly on pinot noir.
We were presented with a document/manifesto called “BELIEVE Southern Ontario Pinot Noir”. For the first time it hatches the broader geographic idea that commonality of the limestone soils ringing Lake Ontario in southern Ontario have created a unique and important place in the world for the production of pinot noir – not just Niagara or Prince Edward County.
It goes on to explain, ‘We are genuinely cool thanks to the stable temperatures of our own Great Lake. Our harvest dates have never moved (despite climate change) and we get long hang time. And we do all this on a limestone bench’
As he and partner Mary Delaney opened the bottles he advised “We are going to taste the pinots first, as they do in Burgundy”, inferring a certain reverence in tackling pinot with a fresh palate.
“And for the first time” he continued “we have bottled more pinots than chardos”. Indeed, of the 2,149 cases of single vineyard wines he produced this vintage, 1,294 are pinot noir and 855 are chardonnay.
During the tasting he revealed frustration and impatience that Niagara pinot is not being as respected as chardonnay, which has proven so successful and popular that it has its own four-day festival every summer called The International Cool Climate Chardonnay Celebration (of which he is a co-founder).
“It’s a colour thing” he said, referring to Niagara’s penchant for producing paler pinots that most other regions on the planet. To paraphrase, it sets up expectation that the wines are weaker, whereas Niagara pinot’s aromas, flavours, texture and depth can be as intense and concentrated as any. “Why can’t people accept Niagara pinot’s characteristics as its signature?’ he asked
For readers not familiar, Thomas Bachelder is a Quebec-born, Burgundy-trained specialist in pinot and chardonnay, who is now immersed in mining Niagara’s terroirs by bottling individual wines from single vineyards east to west along the peninsula. Every November he releases the collection of pinots and chardonnays from the vintage two years prior. In this case 2024.
The Excellent 2024 Pinot Vintage

As interesting as it is to taste the differences between the vineyards, I was more anxious to get a grip on the vintage, which is excellent for pinot noir. And indeed, this was one of the most compelling Bachelder collections I have tasted with ripeness, fragrance, a certain delicacy, crispness and excellent fruit concentration.
The vintage ripened pinot well because it was notably warm throughout the summer and into September. There were fears that considerable, if intermittent, rain during the summer would be a problem. Of all varieties thin-skinned pinot is most susceptible to humidity, which is Niagara’s bane. It causes the tight, compacted bunches to rot easily and quickly. That set’s up acetic and sour flavours in the grapes.
At the end of the 2024 season the heat continued, the skies dried and cooler nights arrived. Says Thomas, “we jumped on the pinot harvest as soon as we saw the ripe flavours, tannins and the seeds turning brown. And the skins were still clean (no fungal activity). As we realized they were not breaking down we held back on some plots and picked them later at maximum ripeness”

And indeed, the ripeness, balance and purity of the 2024 pinots is excellent. I am particularly sensitive to sour acetic acid in pinot noir, but seldom thought about it during this tasting, allowing focus on differences between the wines in terms of vineyard source.
Understanding the differences that location/terroir makes is the whole point of the exercise of course, and it is fascinating. Having done the Touissant tasting four years in a row, I am learning, and now expecting some of the basic structural differences that sites make.
Twenty Mile Bench is now established as the heart of the order of the Bachelder pinot portfolio, with seven of the ten wines hailing from the bench at varying elevations. And they all show a certain intensity, linearity and minerality, that reminds me of Burgundy’s Cotes de Nuit.
As this tasting was conducted with others, and fairly rushed, with all the usual entertaining tangents of tasting with Thomas, I will be repeating it soon at WineAlign under more controlled conditions. I will publish more detailed individual notes and final ratings on the pinots and the chardonnays. But for now, I simply want to show you what pinots are available and impart some stylistic comments.
Ratings-wise they range from 90 to 95 points, with price being an indicator of what’s what, as it should.
The Wines: East to West in Niagara
Bachelder Lowrey Old Vines Pinot Noir 2024,
St. David’s Bench, $65.00
Palest and lightest, lovely strawberry/cherry and florals. Silky and refined. Drink now.
Bachelder Old Eastern Block Lowrey Vineyard Pinot Noir 2024,
St. David’s Bench, $75.00
Pale but deeper than Old Vines. Lifted savoury aromas with sour cherry. Firmer, tart edged, fine tannin. Needs ageing.
Bachelder Cuesta Pinot Noir 2024,
Twenty Mile Bench, $55.00
Deeper garnet colour. Closed nose, savory, earthy, some acetic. More palate intensity and weight than expected. Rugged. Could age long term.
Bachelder Spencer Morgan La Cote Nord Pinot Noir 2024,
Twenty Mile Bench. $60.00
High elevation, pale, lifted, pretty fruit. Lighter, supple, elegant, very fine tannin. A touch sour edged.
Bachelder Spencer Morgan La Cote Sud Pinot Noir 2024,
Twenty Mile Bench, $55.00
Less intense aromas, cherry, foresty notes. Quite firm, tart-edged, fairly tannic. Less distinguished.
Bachelder Wismer Parke Pinot Noir 2023,
Twenty Mile Bench, $65.00
Deeper colour. Lifted sour cherry/ strawberry, evergreen, floral. Mid-weight, firm, rougher-hewn but even. Needs time.
Bachelder Wild West End Wismer Parke Vineyard Pinot Noir 2024,
Twenty Mile Bench, $85.00
Very lifted, complete, floral, pure sour cherry. Great nose. Elegant, energized, satiny. Sour-edged and structured.
Bachelder Hanck Vineyard Pinot Noir 2024,
Twenty Mile Bench, $85.00
Very generous, lovely fruit. Mouth-filling, broad, satiny, more rounded, big fruit palate. Firm tannin. Approachable yet durable.
Bachelder Saunders Parcelle ‘Haut’ Pinot Noir 2024,
Beamsville Bench, $60.00
More garnet, mature colour. Organic. Some fungal/vegetal, very ripe cherry. Quite full, with delicate acid line, minerality.
Bachelder Frontier Block Grimsby Hillside Vineyard Chardonnay 2024,
Lincoln Lakeshore, $60.00
Great aromatic lift with cherry, floral, perfumed. Rich, elegant, satiny and smooth. Very fine tannin. Less depth from young vines.
Availability & Shipping
Mixed lot offerings were sold out within 48 hours of release Nov 1. But individual bottles of all wines are available on-line. Bachelder wines are becoming increasingly more allocated with major retail and restaurant customers in Europe, Quebec and Ontario, and strong sales at the winery (appointments required). They ship ‘direct to consumers’ across Canada with shipping fee waived for orders over $200. Outside of southern Ontario’s urban areas wines are shipped by Canada Post, so shipping by end of November is advised.
Shop here https://bachelderniagara.com/toussaint-release-2026/
